Federal Circuit Affirms Cancellation of Power2B Touch Input Patent in Samsung Victory

Case Overview

The Parties

⚖️ Plaintiff (Appellant)

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.

A global leader in consumer electronics, Samsung successfully defended against a patent assertion concerning touch input technology.

📊 View Patent Portfolio ⚖️ All Litigations

🛡️ Defendant (Appellee)

💡

Power2B, Inc.

An IP-holding entity whose U.S. Patent No. 10,664,070 B2 was found unpatentable by the Federal Circuit.

📊 View Patent Portfolio ⚖️ All Litigations

The Patent at Issue

This case centered on U.S. Patent No. 10,664,070 B2, titled “Input system for controlling electronic devices.” The patent’s claims pertained to methods and systems for user interaction with electronic devices through specialized input mechanisms.

• • US 10,664,070 B2 — Input system for controlling electronic devices

The Verdict & Legal Analysis

Outcome

The Federal Circuit **affirmed** the cancellation of Power2B’s U.S. Patent No. 10,664,070 B2. The court found the patent’s claims to be unpatentable, meaning they failed to meet the statutory requirements for patentability. This decision means the patent can no longer be enforced.

Key Legal Issues

The core of the dispute revolved around the patentability of Power2B’s input system claims. The Federal Circuit’s review likely focused on whether the claimed invention was novel (35 U.S.C. § 102) or obvious (35 U.S.C. § 103) in light of prior art. The specific grounds for unpatentability (e.g., anticipation by a single prior art reference or obviousness based on a combination of references) were not detailed in the available summary, but the outcome confirms the claims were found legally deficient.