Virtual Power Plants & BTM Storage Frequency Regulation
Virtual Power Plants: Aggregating BTM Storage for Frequency Regulation
How virtual power plants aggregate geographically dispersed behind-the-meter storage into dispatchable frequency regulation resources—synthesized from 50+ patents and academic papers across the US, China, EPO, WIPO, and Australia.
SOC Management and Virtual Storage Modeling
The most foundational technical function of a VPP in the context of BTM storage aggregation is maintaining a coherent, dispatchable state across a heterogeneous fleet of distributed energy storage devices. Patent landscape analysis of the Siemens Aktiengesellschaft portfolio (2020) reveals a virtual storage power plant architecture in which distributed electrical energy storage systems are electrically interconnected via transmission lines, a measuring device detects the state of charge (SOC) of each storage unit, and a control device adjusts each unit's SOC between defined lower and upper limits.
Charge equalization is performed by transmitting electrical equalization charges from high-SOC units to low-SOC units, with a mathematical algorithm and predictive power utilization curves guiding the balancing. Without SOC equilibration across the BTM fleet, individual units may be too depleted or saturated to respond to a frequency deviation event.
Elisa OYJ (2023, WO) extends this by introducing real-time plan adjustment. The VPP operates according to a pre-planned schedule for charging or discharging distributed energy storage (DES) devices over a time period to fulfil a power reserve obligation—but the plan is continuously analyzed against predefined acceptance criteria and real-time operating context data, enabling mid-execution adjustments. A companion patent (2024, WO) groups VPP battery assets into a reserve group and active groups; assets are offered for frequency balancing from active groups, while the reserve group is used exclusively for SOC adjustment—a segregation that directly prevents frequency regulation capability from being compromised by internal rebalancing operations.
The concept of virtual storage—treating flexible loads and controllable demand as equivalent to physical batteries—is a significant extension of BTM aggregation. The China Electric Power Research Institute (2019) describes a three-layer architecture (terminal device layer, communication network layer, coordinated control layer) that aggregates controllable loads, distributed renewable generation, electric vehicles, and physical storage devices into a unified virtual storage entity. Research from Aalto University confirms that resources such as PV systems, batteries, and smart loads are individually too small to meet the minimum controllable power thresholds required for frequency reserve markets, making VPP aggregation architecturally necessary.
VPP Patent Landscape: Key Actors & Technical Distribution
Patent activity across leading assignees and technical domain distribution, derived from analysis of 50+ patents and papers in the PatSnap Eureka dataset.
Patent Activity by Leading Assignee
State Grid subsidiaries lead by volume; Elisa OYJ leads internationally with the most focused VPP frequency balancing portfolio.
Technical Domain Distribution in VPP Frequency Regulation Patents
SOC management and hierarchical control dominate the patent corpus, reflecting the core operational prerequisites for BTM aggregation.
From Secondary to Primary Frequency Regulation Services
Frequency regulation spans primary (droop response, seconds), secondary (AGC, minutes), and tertiary (economic dispatch, hours) domains. The patent corpus reveals distinct technical approaches for each.
EMD-Based Multi-Timescale Decomposition
State Grid Jiangxi's 2023 patent uses empirical mode decomposition (EMD) to decompose frequency regulation demand power into high, medium, and low-frequency components, then assigns different VPP resource categories (generation, load, storage) to each frequency band. An aggregated frequency response model is built using power-frequency transfer functions, and real-time optimization is performed using frequency quality metrics as the objective function. This multi-timescale decomposition assigns high-frequency disturbances to fast-responding BTM batteries while slower resources handle medium-frequency components.
EMD decomposition · State Grid Jiangxi, 2023Dynamic VPP on Par with Synchronous Generators
Ecole Centrale Nantes (2022) proposes a control strategy in which Renewable Energy Sources assembled under the Dynamic Virtual Power Plant (DVPP) concept directly participate in Secondary Frequency Control (SFC) under identical specifications to classic synchronous generators. An internal real-time redispatch determines the amount of active power injection by each resource unit, accounting for both rapid (power electronics) and slow (synchronous generator) dynamics. This places VPP-aggregated BTM storage on a contractual and technical parity with conventional spinning reserves. See also ENTSO-E grid code frameworks for secondary frequency control requirements.
DVPP · Ecole Centrale Nantes, 2022Machine Learning for Confidence-Aware Regulation
Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications (2024) directly targets the problem that VPPs have historically pursued self-interest in frequency regulation without accounting for confidence margins or network topology. The invention feeds distributed resource operational data into a pre-trained GCN-BiLSTM (Graph Convolutional Network combined with Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory) predictive model to forecast power output at each VPP aggregation node. Optimal power regulation tasks are then allocated to each node, and system frequency variation is computed—addressing power losses along transmission lines that affect frequency regulation accuracy, an issue that earlier methods ignored.
GCN-BiLSTM · Nanjing Univ, 2024Fair Revenue Allocation Sustains BTM Participation
State Grid Zhejiang (2025) introduces a ramp-function active power output profile for each aggregated storage unit, based on its capacity and state of charge. This ramping approach suppresses frequency deviation in the early stages of a regulation event and enables smooth exit at the conclusion—avoiding a secondary frequency impact from simultaneous disconnection of multiple storage units. Revenue from the overall frequency regulation service is distributed among units based on their quantified contribution to suppressing maximum frequency deviation, computed using dynamic power flow methods.
Revenue distribution · State Grid Zhejiang, 2025Optimization Architectures for Ancillary Service Markets
Frequency regulation ancillary services must be traded in electricity markets before they can be physically delivered. VPP aggregation encompasses both real-time control and market bidding dimensions.
Track emerging VPP market participation patents as they publish
PatSnap Eureka monitors 150M+ patent documents across all major jurisdictions in real time
Key Players Shaping VPP Frequency Regulation IP
The patent corpus spans assignees from Finland, Germany, China, the UK, Spain, and the US—each with distinct technical focus and geographic market alignment.
Elisa OYJ (Finland)
The most prolific international patent holder in the specific domain of VPP-mediated distributed storage control for grid frequency balancing. Their portfolio—including three overlapping WO and US patents on Controlling Distributed Energy Storage System (2023–2025), the third-party asset management method, and the plurality of assets management method—reflects a systematic IP strategy covering plan execution, real-time adjustment, SOC management, and asset activation priority for frequency reserve obligations. Their commercial focus on Northern European frequency reserve markets aligns with Aalto University findings.
Siemens Aktiengesellschaft (Germany)
Established early foundational patents in virtual storage power plants. Both the Virtual Power Plant (2017) and Virtual Power Plant (2020) patents cover SOC equalization across distributed storage interconnected via transmission networks—the core architectural prerequisite for any aggregated frequency regulation service. Siemens's early filings established the IP foundation that later actors have built upon. Patent analytics confirm these as anchor citations across the corpus.
What the Patent Evidence Tells Us About VPP-BTM Integration
VPPs enable BTM storage to cross the market participation threshold. Individual behind-the-meter storage assets are too small to independently qualify for frequency reserve markets. Aggregation through a VPP provides the minimum controllable power block required, as established by Aalto University (2021). This architectural necessity is the foundational rationale for the entire VPP-BTM-frequency regulation innovation stack. The WIPO patent database reflects growing international filings in this domain.
SOC management is the core operational prerequisite. Without active state-of-charge balancing across the distributed fleet, individual assets may be unavailable when frequency events occur. Siemens's Virtual Power Plant (2017) and Elisa OYJ's asset grouping method (2024) both address this, with Elisa segregating SOC adjustment into a dedicated reserve group to avoid compromising active frequency regulation capacity.
Simultaneous multi-market participation multiplies BTM storage value. Restricting BTM storage to a single market forfeits revenue opportunities. Ayesa (2022) demonstrates that combining dynamic storage virtualization with model predictive control enables simultaneous participation in day-ahead energy and frequency reserve markets, improving asset economics and encouraging BTM storage deployment. The PatSnap platform tracks multi-market optimization filings across jurisdictions.
Distributed price-signal optimization reduces central computation burden. As BTM fleet sizes grow, centralized optimization becomes computationally intractable. Xi'an Jiaotong University (2023) shows that parallel resource-level optimization against a shared frequency regulation price signal converges to market-clearing solutions without requiring a central solver to model all assets simultaneously. For regulatory context, see FERC Order 841 on energy storage participation in frequency regulation markets.
Virtual Power Plants & BTM Storage — key questions answered
Individual behind-the-meter storage assets are too small to independently qualify for frequency reserve markets. Aggregation through a VPP provides the minimum controllable power block required, as established by research from Aalto University (2021) on Northern European primary frequency reserve markets.
SOC balancing is the active equalization of charge levels across a distributed fleet of storage devices. Without it, individual assets may be too depleted or saturated to respond to a frequency deviation event. Siemens's Virtual Power Plant patents (2017, 2020) describe mathematical algorithms and predictive power utilization curves that transmit equalization charges from high-SOC units to low-SOC units. Elisa OYJ further segregates SOC adjustment into a dedicated reserve group to avoid compromising active frequency regulation capacity.
EMD decomposes frequency regulation demand power into high, medium, and low-frequency components, then assigns different VPP resource categories (generation, load, storage) to each frequency band. State Grid Jiangxi's 2023 patent demonstrates EMD-based decomposition assigning high-frequency disturbances to fast-responding BTM batteries while medium and low-frequency components are handled by slower resources—enabling multi-timescale regulation across the VPP fleet.
State Grid Zhejiang's 2025 patent proposes quantifying each unit's contribution to maximum frequency deviation suppression as the basis for revenue sharing. A ramp-function active power output profile is applied to each aggregated storage unit based on its capacity and state of charge, and revenue is distributed among units based on their quantified contribution to suppressing maximum frequency deviation, computed using dynamic power flow methods.
Yes. Research from Ayesa, Spain (2022) demonstrates that combining dynamic storage virtualization with model predictive control enables simultaneous participation in day-ahead energy and frequency reserve markets. The first stage optimizes the day-ahead bidding strategy; a control stage then mitigates real-time deviations and potential penalties—improving asset economics and encouraging BTM storage deployment.
Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications (2024) applies GCN-BiLSTM (Graph Convolutional Network combined with Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory) models to predict aggregation node power output and compute confidence-aware optimal regulation tasks. This directly addresses the problem that conventional VPP frequency control methods lack confidence margin awareness and network topology sensitivity, reducing the risk of VPP frequency regulation failure.
Still have questions? Let PatSnap Eureka answer them for you.
Ask Eureka About VPP PatentsAccelerate Your VPP & Energy Storage R&D with AI Patent Intelligence
Join 18,000+ innovators already using PatSnap Eureka to accelerate their R&D. Search 150M+ patents, map competitive landscapes, and identify white spaces in frequency regulation technology.
References
- Virtual Power Plant — Siemens Aktiengesellschaft, 2020
- Virtual Power Plant — Siemens Aktiengesellschaft, 2017
- Controlling Distributed Energy Storage System — Elisa OYJ, 2023 (WO)
- Controlling Distributed Energy Storage System — Elisa OYJ, 2023 (WO, second filing)
- Controlling Distributed Energy Storage System — Elisa OYJ, 2025 (US)
- Computer-implemented method for managing a plurality of assets of a virtual power plant — Elisa OYJ, 2024 (WO)
- Computer-implemented method for managing a plurality of third party assets of a virtual power plant — Elisa OYJ, 2025 (WO)
- A Virtual Power Plant Solution for Aggregating Photovoltaic Systems and Other Distributed Energy Resources for Northern European Primary Frequency Reserves — Aalto University, 2021
- Direct Participation of Dynamic Virtual Power Plants in Secondary Frequency Control — Ecole Centrale Nantes-LS2N, 2022
- Frequency Regulation Method Using Active Support of Virtual Power Plants — Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications, 2024
- A Day-Ahead and Real-Time Frequency Regulation Method for Virtual Power Plants Based on EMD — State Grid Jiangxi Electric Power Co., 2023
- A Frequency Regulation Revenue Distribution Method for Electricity-Storage-Aggregated Virtual Power Plants — State Grid Zhejiang Shaoxing Power Supply Co., 2025
- VPP Load-Side Resource Distributed Regulation Method and System — Xi'an Jiaotong University, 2023
- A Virtual Storage Coordinated Control System and Method — China Electric Power Research Institute, 2019
- Intent Profile Strategy for Virtual Power Plant Participation in Simultaneous Energy Markets With Dynamic Storage Management — Ayesa, Spain, 2022
- Virtual Power Plant Power Resource Scheduling Method, Electronic Device and Storage Medium — State Grid Shanghai Electric Power Company, 2025
- Optimal Dispatch Strategy for Virtual Power Plants with Adjustable Capacity Assessment of High-Energy-Consuming Industrial Loads Participating in Ancillary Service Markets — Northeastern University, 2023
- Virtual Power Plant Interoperability — Nokia Solutions and Networks OY, 2024 (US)
- Virtual power station — Responsiveload Limited, 2012 (WO)
- VPP Regulation Capability Fast Allocation Method, Apparatus, Device and Medium — State Grid Shanghai Energy Internet Research Institute, 2023
- Considering Physical and Control Constraints Virtual Power Plant Regulation Capability Assessment Method and System — Global Energy Internet Group, 2024
- Role of Aggregator in Coordinating Residential Virtual Power Plant in "StoreNet": A Pilot Project Case Study — Solo Energy-SMS Plc, Ireland, 2022
- WIPO — World Intellectual Property Organization Patent Database
- FERC — Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Order 841: Energy Storage Participation in Markets Operated by RTOs and ISOs
- ENTSO-E — European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity, Network Codes & Grid Connection Requirements
All data and statistics on this page are sourced from the references above and from PatSnap's proprietary innovation intelligence platform.
PatSnap Eureka searches patents and research to answer instantly.